Introduction
So, as all of you know (unless you're living under a rock), the long-anticipated movie of the new DC Extended Universe, Batman vs Superman has been released. The movie was met with negative critic reviews, with some calling it insufferable, while others straight-up calling it an insult to the two titular characters.
By all expectations, the movie was expected to be another costly failure for WB production studios. Yet, when the movie was released, it broke several financial records, and was met with a far more lukewarm reception from the audience. The internet is still divided regarding the movie, with some liking it, and others calling it a piece of garbage. This is my take on the movie.
WARNING: This blog post will contain some spoilers. Before reading further, it is advised you see the movie. You have been warned.
Review
Plot
Introduction
The plot for Batman vs Superman:Dawn of Justice is essentially exactly what the movie says. It's Batman vs Superman, and a precursor to the Justice League. Allow me to explain further.
This movie is set roughly one and half year after the events of Man of Steel. Bruce Wayne witnesses the destruction of Metropolis first hand, and begins to prepare to take down Superman in the eventuality that Superman ever goes rogue. He dons his cape again (which he hung up years ago, presumably after the death of Jason Todd, a.k.a. Robin), and begins to plan for the fight.
Batman is aged, and embittered by the futility of his life's work in the face of the potential threat Superman poses. Angry and driven to extremes, his actions take a decisively dark turn (such as branding criminals). His butler Alfred, his sole companion, is quick to point out that "the feeling of powerlessness turns good men cruel".
On the other hand, Superman is presented with his own set of challenges. His actions, no matter how noble, are received with mixed reactions from people across the globe. The continuous fear of his unchecked authority causes frustration to build up in Superman. Additionally, the events around him are manipulated in a manner which portray him as a villain.
In the background is the demented genius Lex Luthor, subtly manipulating events which cause the inevitable clash between the two, in order to further his own agenda.
Summary
The first half of the movie focuses less on action, and more on the set-up for the conflict (apart from a sweet action scene involving the Batmobile, which was better than any car sequence Fast and Furious ever managed). The perspectives of both the titular characters are explored in depth, and the groundwork for the fight is laid out.
There are also dream sequences depicted, which are a definite nod-off to comic book readers, but may cause minor confusion for those not well acquainted with DC Comics. It's irrelevant to the plot of the movie itself, so if you don't understand the dream sequences, don't worry about them mid-movie (Google the explanation later on).
The second half is far more action-oriented, with a brutal slam-down between the Dark Knight and the Man of Steel. Unlike the amazing fight between Captain America and the Winter Soldier (from the excellent movie, Captain America:The Winter Soldier), which was quite technical, the fight here is raw and brutal. Every punch thrown is intended to cause some serious hurt, and the fight itself has twists and turns. The fight is short (not more than 10 minutes long), but the narrative build-up until this point, coupled with the excellent choreography, make every moment worth it.
This is followed by another fight between the Trinity and the Kryptonian deformity created by Luthor (not named, only referred to as "Superman's Doomsday"), in a last bid attempt to get rid of Superman. Once again, the fight sequence is excellent, with Doomsday overpowering the brawling Superman, and attempting to fry Batman (who can do little more than run at this point). Only Wonder Woman (depicted to be a skilled warrior) is able to match the monster on equal footing. It should be noted however, that at this point, the fight gets a little loud and a little heavy on the CGI.
Overall
The plot, while not negligible, was definitely one of the weaker points of the film, being spread too thin. However, it was simple and coherent enough to follow, force-inserted dream sequences notwithstanding.
Overall, I would give it 7/10.
Characters
Superman
Superman is well played by Henry Cavill. The character is shown to have grown since the last film, now embracing his "superhero" persona image. However, he still remains wary of working with official authorities. He's not a self-assured bot-scout, like the character played by Christopher Reeve. On one occasion, he develops a conflict of whether he's truly doing the right thing (a contemplation any regular person would engage in, were he boo'ed by half the world). Cavill makes another great performance, reprising his role of the modern-day Superman with ease.
Batman
Undoubtedly the stand-out performance of the movie, Batman, played by Ben Affleck, also termed as "Batfleck", delivers one of the most solid performances of Batman seen in cinematic history. Ben Affleck beautifully plays the role of the jaded, bitter, crime-fighting Bat-themed vigilante of Gotham city, breathing life into Frank Miller's adaptation of the character from the comic book, The Dark Knight Returns.
Similar to the comic book, the more experienced and more savage Batman is willing to cross the line with his age-old "no-killing" rule. While this might as well incite a cry of "BLASPHEMY!" from die-hard Batman fans, I personally don't mind the change (and yes, I'm also a Batman fan), because characters EVOLVE over time. It's ridiculous, childish, and quite simply, old-fashioned to dislike a character for modifying an element of the pre-set mythos. Once again, I think it's better to keep an open mind, and accept the characters as they are represented, not as we personally want them to be.
All in all, divisive change aside, Ben Affleck does a tremendous job in bringing the character of Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns to life.
Lex Luthor
Jesse Eisenberg's performance as Lex Luthor was disappointing. His manipulations were deft, and reeked of ingenuity, but the psychotic, quirky behaviour felt forced and over-the-top, and his lines generally felt clunky and out-of-place. Again, the character was out of touch with his comic book version, and again, I would have accepted the adaptational behavioural difference, were the execution not as jarring and awkward.
Wonder Woman
Wonder Woman in this movie is absolutely fascinating. She is confident, suave, and quite self-assured. When in combat, she's a flat-out badass. I was initially skeptical of the casting choice, and extremely please to note that my skepticism was entirely unfounded, and that this adaptation of the character might very well be the female superhero we've all been waiting for. Gadot's role is a bit short, just enough to generate interest for her prequel film, and boy, am I pumped for it.
Lois Lane
Amy Adams reprises the role of tough journalist and Superman's romantic interest, Lois Lane. She does an alright job, but the role is nothing particularly special. Her role is decently done, although the chemistry between her and Superman is still lacking.
Alfred Pennyworth
If anyone asks me what is the best part about the movie, my response will be the same every single time: "Jeremy Irons". The sarcastic, slightly cheeky version of the character is quite possibly the best incarnation of the character. As beloved as Michael Caine's version was, the Dark Knight trilogy adaptation of the character gave off a stricly butler-like vibe, unlike this version, who is an equally competent sidekick, helping Batman with his operations.
Others
Ma Kent, played by Diane Lane, is as graceful as ever, imparting wisdom and emotional support, yet realistically displaying a selfish instinct of keeping her son safe (an instinct ingrained in every parent).
Perry White was back to his grumpy, headline-selling nature. Once again, Laurence Fishburn really nails the role.
Holly Hunter also does a decent job as Senator Finch, playing a tough, yet responsible politician.
There are plenty of other characters, but none of them of particular note.
Overall
I loved the characterizations presented in Batman vs Superman, and with the exception of Jesse Eisenberg, was pleased with their performances.
Overall, I would give it 9/10.
Entertainment
This movie was incredibly entertaining. I waited for it for 2+ years, and it delivered on all fronts. The action was spectacular, the characterizations were well done, the cameos and hints were awesome, and the plot was decent for a set-up movie. For entertainment value, I would rate this 10/10.
Summary
In the end, I loved Batman vs Superman. It wasn't perfect by any means, but it was definitely great, and I would give it 8.2/10 overall. I'm interested in hearing all your opinions, however. Did you like it? Hate it? Whatever you think, comment below, and let me know :)
P.S. While I generally don't mind people having a differing opinion, there are some overused, nonsensical reasons for disliking the movie such as:
- It was too dark!
- Batman doesn't kill!
- You're not a true comic book fan!
It's perfectly fine to dislike the film (in fact, I would like to hear your reasons for it). However, if your answer contains any of the listed phrases, please, keep your opinion to yourself.