This is a thread to report profiles and pages, that users come across, that are sorely lacking in justifications, have poor formatting, are almost empty of content, or are otherwise unacceptable by our wiki's standards.
Please report any such profiles to this thread to see if the profiles are liable for deletion, or if they can be revised with help from the staff or regular members.
It should be noted that while regular users can report poorly made profiles, or make a quick note that they are able to help out with fixing a faulty page, only staff members are allowed to discuss whether or not they should be deleted, as othervise this thread would quickly turn unmanageable from the sheer number of responses.
However, if you would like to contribute to the conversation, please leave a message on a staff member's wall.
Note: It is highly recommended that all staff members subscribe to this thread, by clicking the "follow" button in the upper right corner of this post.
Edit: I just took a look at all profiles and yeah. Delete all of it, because there is too many unmotivated statistics and some have seriously poor explanations.
Unless there is someone who is reading the manga currently i would say the profiles need to be deleted cause i finished reading it quite some time ago and i can only fix only that much on their profiles for now.
So, summarise: unless there is someone who can take care of them right now i suggest you delete the profiles and i will see to just remake the verse ones i read the entire thing again.
Saikou The Lewd King wrote:
It wasn't. At all. Honestly, the goddamn hills in Super Mario World are more phallic than this character was. Can I at least get the permission to remake the profile without a picture?
I can just restore it and remove the image if you want.
There's also no calcs on the profile either, and it's not like the justifications link to a profile either, striking strength is written as "Planet level" instead of Planet Class (although that's a simple fix)
Her rule was to be defeated by Post Timeskip Base Dark Schneider and solidify the 5-B rating, after that Dark and Satan would have soon fought, but then the manga went on hiatus and i'm unsure if it was finished in japan.
Okay, this may be just my personal opinion, but a lot of Bleach profiles have unnecesary large walls of text.
Take for example Ichigo Kurosaki, it has FIVE TABBERS, each one with a HUGE WALL OF TEXT, just to explain basic things like "Enhaced Strength", "Enhaced Speed", "Enhanced Durability", "Swordmanship", etc.
I think Noriko Takaya should be deleted, the profile is a complete mess, the reasoning for her being small town level is "Able to damage other RX-7 suits alike in duels, which can withstand the intensity of relativistic velocity environments" that's not a legitimate reason to be small town level.
Likewise she is planet level to likely small star level for "easily vaporized at least tens of thousands, possibly millions, of cruiser-class Space Monsters in a single blast, which can withstand the internal heat and pressure of a yellow star indefinitely" which isn't a legit reason to be planet level or small star level either, since being able to withstand the heat of a star is multi-city block level, not planet level.
"This is a thread to report profiles and pages, that users come across, that are sorely lacking in justifications, have poor formatting, are almost empty of content, or are otherwise unacceptable by our wiki's standards."
Should Isaac McDougal be kept? Although he only appears in the 2009 anime, he is portrayed in a serious light, wouldn't look out of place if he appeared in the Manga as well, and considering we keep profiles like Zephyr (One Piece)...
^ What are the justifications for his stats? I can understand labelling someone 10-A or 9-C and leaving it at that. But for 9-B and higher ratings, there must be some sort of justification. Same for speed. Peak Human movement speed? No problem. He has Superhuman reactions? Okay but why?
I see nothing wrong with that page besides the unjustified Subsonic rating. And it has proper formatting and stuff. It doesn't matter if it isn't "that big" of a profile. Only problem would be if the statistics are inaccurate.
That profile gave me a headache. Regardless of what Everlasting says, I'm not against deleting that profile. We did so once with the Quinlan Vos profile (deleted it outright and had someone rewrite it entirely).
Personally, I think we should wait for the maker of those pages, DiceyTheDie before we do anything, as he is an active user, or at least, more active than the creators of many of those no-profile verse pages.
Profiles for established web series with original content and characters are allowed. Red vs Blue and RWBY are examples. I myself plan on making profiles for an Indian made comedy web series (original content and characters) and got the green light from Ryukama.
"All characters in VS Battles wiki profiles should originate within actual stories, from notable or popular works."
"Do not create any joke profiles, as they do not fit into our tiering system. Also avoid creating profiles for fan characters, advertisement characters, YouTube personalities, music videos, memes, and the like. If you wish to create such profiles, feel free to do so in the Joke Battles wiki instead."
So as long as they originate within popular coherent storylines, it should be okay.
Kind've messed up on these a bit. Please forgive me, I'm new to creating wiki pages from scratch. If possible, I can redo these with the Anime page I plan to do later this week. When I'll have enough time to take care of it all together.
Eh...i think its detailed enough, i would leave it
It is accurate, but it does not have any links or images linking to her statistics.
It would be easier just to delete the page.
She is non combative anyway as well as having alot of speculation around her as a character
More than half the pages dont have links to their power, its mainly based off powerscaling. she has an explanation for her tiering so its fine. And theres loads of non combative pages aswell, such as Richard Watterson. as long as it has decent quality and justifications, its fine
Why do we have Calvin and Hobbes profiles? The only feats come from his own imagination.
The one profile we have is for Spaceman Spiff who can be considered his own character within Calvin's imaginary world. Whether it is up to standards is the question. And I don't think it is. So what do other staff members think?
Sorry. I didn't think someone was working on feats & profiles for that verse seeing as how it was left untouched for a whole damn year. If you want, you can ask me on my message wall later to restore it. And then you can work on fixing up that verse page.
To answer your question, they are far different. Moon Kotarou is his appearance as a conceptual being containing all his previous lives. Terra Kotarou is him from a new timeline created by Moon Kotarou to save the Earth.
1) I deleted a LN verse on the basis that i and Reppuzan have found to be outdated on top of MAYBE having most of it's info (outside of stats and all) taken from it's wikia called "Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei" that i will be overlooking this verse via reading its' LN series...when i get more time and energy and motivation to do it that is.
Just to bring this up.
2) Should we delete this page of Composite Mickey here? I'm like not getting anything worth having this around any longer considering when we had a time from a year if not two ago that it was going to have more stuff but...nothings come up out of it so...can we delete it?
It's not exactly a composite when the most it's got is from like....3 incarnations of Mickey AFAIK of this page. Maybe there's more than i'm giving it out there, but i'm not seeing a complete version of this at all so....
I've made a thread that discussed the removal of specific building tools on the ROBLOXian's profile. It's been 20 days without any input, so I basically removed the tools from the ROBLOxian's profile, and I'm requesting for the above profile to be removed, too.
Not sure if this is the right place or not, but i have a really strong grip regarding the Kongou Banchou verse that i have to get off my chest of.
Basically, i feel like the stats outside of the 6-A's of the top tiers seem really...weird, to me. In the sense that i, having read the series from start to finish not once but twice, feel they need a complete refresh/reworking along with the verse page needing a complete makeover. So...i was thinking of maybe deleting it all here and then start to compile stuff for it as a sort of "feats blog" or "respect blog" of the characters in the series. Or just leave them as is for now and just do the compiling part.
Though if i had to choose, i'd rather actually delete them completely and start back up from sctratch and, if possible, gather feats of the characters that i feel would need to be calc'd or even recalc'd.
Any thoughts/opinions about all this? Deleting them, again at least IMO, would actually make my later work of this a lot easier to do but still just asking...
Thing is, their calc is from Narutoforums and considering we normally can't access them lest one makes an NF account to view them and such, there's nothing much i can do about them with anything so....
So what do you suggest i do with that then? The ones i recall having all valid calc links are the two brothers and Machine Banchou here who has a speed calc that scales to a few. Can't remember who, just know that it does.
Most of the others in scaling, i feel it's still necessary for me to take them out and rework them from scratch.
It would make my work a lot easier to deal with, yes.
And as said, i plan to actually go back and reread the manga fully (which is not hard at all since it's pretty damn good and enjoyable, making my work even faster to deal with) while compiling all feats for it and, again if possible, have ones that either need to be calc'd or even others that i feel would need a check up on calc'ing.
Anyways, i deleted most of them but ones that do have calc's linked to them so i'll check to see if they are saved and shown or not. Either way, i may have them be needed for recalc'ing or whatever depending if it's needed.
Best part is, that page wasn't lacking information, it was just the most jumbled mess of source code I've ever seen.
Yeah. Would have been simpler to just delete the damn profile and rewrite it from scratch. That's what we did with the Quinlan Vos profile. It was such a bloody mess that I told Antvasima to just delete it and let me write it again from scratch.
In its current state, this profile is unfixable. She is apparently street level and galaxy level at the same time, which means i can't clean this up because i don't know what tier she truly is, not to mention the jumbled mess of source code present in the page.
There's no such thing as "delete because it's obscure" or "delete because its "l"not necessary to have'" as who's the one to determine whether or not something is "unnecessary" when it doesn't even go against our standards? Untranslated? Last I checked so was the Masadaverse until Ven came along and we now have ALRF and an English localization.
When I get to it, I'll redo the Golovachev pages with proper explanations, as I said so I was going to do, remember?, of course I'll translate everything relevant.
Also (not referring to this profile, but rather speaking in general), we have to use some common sense in terms of a reasonable amount of notability. We cannot feature obscure unpublished or barely read fan works, for example.
Okay, this is more question about a deleted profile.
Just yesterday a manage to create a profile for X-O Manowar (Aric of Dacia), a character from Valiant Comics, and today I when I was about to add two images for his gallery, puff, it disappeared.
I don't know why, because I'm 100% sure that I did the profile well, and even then, someone could have gave me a message about it, instead of straigth foward delete the profile without even letting me know.
I deleted it because the statistics seemed to be placed purely on guesswork, and I am so overworked nowadays that I did not have the time to correct them all to unknown ratings, which would turn it into a deletion candidate anyway. In addition, Antoniofer is currently slowly creating various Valiant profiles, so he will likely get to this character eventually.
Okay, though I would have liked that at least get a message...
I put "Likely" in most of his stats because as far I know, survive the destruction of a planet's surface is justified as a High 6-A feat, but there was not a calc for it (Or at least one I know), so I used the "Likely" because there was not a calc for how much yielded the feat.