This is a thread to report profiles and pages, that users come across, that are sorely lacking in justifications, have poor formatting, are almost empty of content, or are otherwise unacceptable by our wiki's standards.
Please report any such profiles to this thread to see if the profiles are liable for deletion, or if they can be revised with help from the staff or regular members.
It should be noted that while regular users can report poorly made profiles, or make a quick note that they are able to help out with fixing a faulty page, only staff members are allowed to discuss whether or not they should be deleted, as othervise this thread would quickly turn unmanageable from the sheer number of responses.
However, if you would like to contribute to the conversation, please leave a message on a staff member's wall.
Note: It is highly recommended that all staff members subscribe to this thread, by clicking the "follow" button in the upper right corner of this post.
I request Ditto due to well, it VARIES. All bad jokes aside Ditto is nothing more than a copycat who, when transforms copies almost everthing minus hp of its opponent if im not mistaken, which could be a big disadvantage depending on it's and it's opponents health. Further more there is just not enough imformation to rank Ditto as a stand alone character. Bassiclly Ditto is nothing without it's adversary.
Annin from Dragon Ball should be deleted. She is a non-important filler character who only appears in one episode and is never mentioned again. On top of that she isn't popular like the moie characters, and never appears in any games or dragon ball media.
God-King Superman77 wrote: Annin from Dragon Ball should be deleted. She is a non-important filler character who only appears in one episode and is never mentioned again. On top of that she isn't popular like the moie characters, and never appears in any games or dragon ball media.
SCRUB LORD 21 wrote: I request Ditto due to well, it VARIES. All bad jokes aside Ditto is nothing more than a copycat who, when transforms copies almost everthing minus hp of its opponent if im not mistaken, which could be a big disadvantage depending on it's and it's opponents health. Further more there is just not enough imformation to rank Ditto as a stand alone character. Bassiclly Ditto is nothing without it's adversary.
This is an indexing wikia so his viability in vs battles is not our first priority.
Personally, I don't care if the profile stays or goes. It ruined the flow of the "Trainers" section anyway. But take a look at these verses. If they're not related to Nasu, Masada, the seagull series, or Demonbane, they're very obscure.
I apologize if the work seems sloppy. I wasn't particularly invested in the series and didn't read past the first few chapters since I just wanted to make it look somewhat presentable. In addition, only a handful of chapters have been released thus far: the first ten chapters and the last three chapters, with nothing in between. These are the most concrete feats I could find without resorting to asking for calcs.
I'll go through the few chapters I can find to find anything more solid, but I really don't have a lot to go on.
I'm also against deleting profiles because of obscurity. One profile I made, Arago Hunt, has a good deal of feats and such, but I highly doubt that more than a handful of people are aware of its existence.
I don't think profiles should be deleted for being obscure, though. Notability is relative. To some people, games like Phantasy Star and Musashi are utter classics, and others have never even heard of them.
As long as a series is official, it should be okay to keep around.
I'd argue that a lot of "obscure" manga/anime/visual novels simply aren't known in english circles and are likely only popular in Japan, so "no one knows about them on the wiki" doesn't seem to be a good excuse imo.
Thing is, a large amount of site views comes from western countries. I'm not just saying "Murica", but Brazil, Mexico, Canada, Western Europe, Russian speaking places. And while yeah, a handful of us are from eastern places, that's not the majority. So they are pretty obscure for this website's viewers.
Also, @SD. Did you mean that in terms of obscurity, ReBURST is less obscure than some of the VNs, or that ReBURST is less opposite-of-obscure compared to some of the VNs.
Considering that I've only heard about ReBurst on this site and a YouTube video discussing the weirdest and most obscure parts of the Pokemon merchandise...I think it's pretty obscure. Not deletion worthy though.
The Overmind is an incredibly shallow page that is not up to our standards. It has zero summary, has no "Others" category, is missing stats, its organization is off, and lacks good reasoning for its stats outside of its Attack Potency, which is still somewhat questionable (is rocking the solar system only Star level?).
"Rocking" would imply Earthquakes across each planet, which can vary greatly in the results. Dunno would a full on Solar System "Earthquake" would yield, so I think "At least 4-C" would be fine considering 4-C is such a small tier.
I added in additional stats it was missing and reorganized it to follow our format. Still lacks any summary and it has almost entirely Unknowns for its stats. Lacking any summary or stats feels extremely empty even after the cleaning.
Well, they are not treated as omnipotent entities, are prominent parts of their games, and I think that the rest of the staff would prefer to keep them around, so I suppose that we can make an exception.
False. Ganondorf is immortal. He has died a couple times, sure. In the classic Zelda and in Wind Waker, but other than that it results in sealing. Regardless, he does not have the same reincarnation cycle as the knight and princess.
The real cal howard wrote: False. Ganondorf is immortal. He has died a couple times, sure. In the classic Zelda and in Wind Waker, but other than that it results in sealing. Regardless, he does not have the same reincarnation cycle as the knight and princess.
In Skyward Sword, Demise made the reincarnation cycle in the first place, and he made it the same as theirs. He died there and in Twilight Princess also.
I deleted the Carmen Sandiego profile. The feat involving the Black Hole at the center of the galaxy was done through outside help, and took time, as it involved the construction of a technology around it.
The "High 3-A" is unquantifiable, and involves applying Reality Warping powers to an Educational Game.
Mary's profile was all sorts of messed up. It had durability listed as "Superhuman", had no summary, and the profile picture was placed in the wrong area. If you want to know exactly what I'm talking about, then just take a look at the version of it when it was first made.
I gave it a general makeover a while back, but now I think it's better off being deleted.
While I'm almost certain some of the explanations are reliable, this profile doesn't follow the preferred format. It mentions some statistics in the wrong order and includes an entirely different section of abilities labelled "Via pet".
I definitely do not want to undo all of the effort that's been put into this profile, because there is a LOT of stuff mentioned. I think it's just the incorrectly ordered statistics that need to be arranged.
I want Vampire Hunter D's profile to be deleted. to quote myself from another thread:
Matthew Schroeder wrote: Also, D's profile is chalk-full with NLFs and things without any proof. Just look at this:
"D's attacks cuts through the fount of life itself, something that is much more fundamental and abstract than the soul. There is no possible way to recover from a wound dealt by cutting through the fount of life, and if you die you will stay dead"
Who says so? That just sounds like something that'd require Mid-Godly Regen to come back or endure, and can he kill stronger people with it?
"D can't be erased from history, as he is immune to the Akashic Records, and thus immune to reality warper's powers"
Really? Immune to Reality Warping?
The "Respect Thread" linked on D's profile (Also made by the guy who made D's profile) is also chalk full with similarly absurd claims:
The quote the guy shows to "prove" that the Akashic Records control everything is super vague, too, and doesn't at all show what it's said on D's profile:
"but what the Sacred Ancestor has to say is even more incredible. He says I should erase this world completely from the record"
"He could read the record. The past, present, and future of everything in the universe"
How do these give you anything beyond complete control over a universe's timeline is beyond me.
The quote about the fount of life is also bullshit:
"This wound was dealt by someone with skill equal to my own. He cut through not only flesh and bone, but through the fount of life. No one, god or demon, can help you now."
^ This just implies that he killed a soul.
The scene supposed to show that D can bypass "physical laws" is also stupid:
"The top of his traveler's hat hit the ceiling. Now lying completely flat, D drew his sword. It was pitted against ultradense walls that wouldn't allow even electromagnetic waves or light to escape. There was the sound of bones creaking behind him. D thrusted his sword. Miranda and Count Braujou saw it slide into the wall like a mirage. Glowing cracks spread out around them. No one knew how the black hole collapsed."
^ It's just him destroying a black hole, nothing about bypassing all laws of physics like the profile implies.
His feat of breaking through an "Eternally sealed dimension" just shows that he can fuck-up with the timeline. Nothing beyond Low 2-C at best.
The respect thread also says that D is "Immune to Matter Manipulation" because he negated being transmuted into a star.
All in all, I see no proof that D is nearly as haxed as the profile says he is, and consider it completely unreliable. It should be deleted.
Lucina and Lucina (Future Past) are the exact same profile, I think we should remove the latter and put a note on the former saying that the 2nd key was from events in Future Past (and also the same Lucina from the Future Past timeline), either that or remove the 2nd key from the former
@Rep: Nah. Keep it deleted. I doubt we have anybody that's actually willing to read through such a series like this. Especially if what Matt said is true of it where some are either NLF-ish or wanked or whatnot.
There are many things wrong with this profile. I'd do it myself but I'm on a phone. For starters, it's a fake triforce in what amounts to a virtual theme park, so that's moot. It's Supersonic+ for a feat that's subsonic. The 9-A "feat" comes from beating an enemy that would be Low wall level (I've played the game. It's nowhere near 9-A in size) and beating a lot of enemies that are street level at best. Finally, it's overall a Mii profile that likely breaks our non-canon rules.
This profile is an extremely high tiered character, is locked because of that, yet has virtually no information or justification. No summary, no picture, abilities with no justification or reasoning, and only 1 justification for any stat period.
On top of that, the 1 justification is terrible. It is listed as High 1-B for destroying "multidimensional star systems" (so... a solar system that is higher dimensional? Maybe? Who knows, it doesn't say.) which can be "potentially" infinite in dimensions. So in what world does being possibly High 1-B (at most, really, since if you were 1-A you would be beyond dimensions and would need a completely different feat to justify that ranking) mean you're at least High 1-B? That implies you could possibly 1-A or even 0, which there isn't any feat or attempt at justification for.