A battle royale between four priests (well three and a nun). All start at their strongest, Enrico has Whitesnake and C-Moon but does not have Made in Heaven. In character, no prior knowledge or prep time, Victory by KO, Death, or incapacitation. Takes place at Beacon Academy.
R1: Double has regeneration that prevents Pucci's hax from killing her and enough AP to put everyone else down. She can also take a couple hits from Pucci, although beating him first is probably the best idea for her. Garterbelt isn't functionally immortal without Panty and Stocking. Anderson's weakness is his heart, which is easy enough to crush.
R2: Garterbelt has a speed advantage that can't be overcome. Only Pucci can react to him and Garter has ranged weapons so its useless anyways.
Yea, in speed equal, Ciel absolutely destroys everyone else. She kept up with 30% Arc and surpassed her in magic form, is capable of killing on a conceptual level and has disgustingly good regeneration. Even in the speed unequal round I would still give it to her 9/10 times, with the one time she loses being when Pucci and Garterbelt team up to kill her (because Pucci should be able to hax her down).