Theodore pony

Theodore crusader

Note: This profile contains major spoilers for the game Pony Island. Continue at your own risk.


Theodore is the name of the game's main character, whose soul is trapped in limbo. Like all lost souls, Theodore remembers nothing of his life, though he can remember small portions of who he was by finding the hidden demon Baphomet. After finding Baphomet enough times, it is revealed Theodore was a crusader from the 1200s who was killed during an assault on Jerusalem by a man named Abu Al-Kindi. Theodore left behind a wife and daughter, and was presumably sent to limbo due to his crimes as a crusader. Throughout the game, he will work with Hopeless Soul in order to escape his imprisonment, eventually leading an army of lost souls (in the form of Pony Island's playable ponies) to freedom and escaping the clutches of the Devil.

Powers and Stats

Tier: Low 2-C, possibly far higher

Name: Theodore, "Guest", The pony

Origin: Pony Island

Gender: Male

Age: Unknown at the time of his death. His soul has presumably been in limbo for centuries, though time does not matter, there.

Classification: Former crusader, Lost soul, Pony

Powers and Abilities: Superhuman strength, speed, and durability, Pony Wings, Immortality (Type 7), Regeneration (Low-Godly), Data Manipulation, Soul Manipulation, Spatial Manipulation, Energy Manipulation, Pony Lasers, Air Manipulation

Attack Potency: Universe level+ (Easily destroyed Beelzebub.exe, who should be on par with Azazel.exe and Asmodeus.exe due to being one of the three daemonic A.I. tasked with guarding a core file), possibly far higher (Defeated Lucifer's avatar and Hopeless Soul, though they were not fighting to their fullest nor were they permanently damaged)

Speed: Unknown (Kept up with Lucifer and Beelzebub.exe)

Lifting Strength: Unknown

Striking Strength: Unknown

Durability: Unknown. Likely Universe level+ (Capable of recovering from Beelzebub.exe's hits and Hopeless Soul's casual attacks), possibly far higher (Recovered from attacks from Lucifer, albeit at the cost of other souls)

StaminaLikely limitless


Standard Equipment: Pony Wings, Pony Lasers

IntelligencePresumably quite high, as he is capable of solving numerous puzzles and hacking into Pony Island

Weaknesses: None notable


Notable Victories:

Notable Losses:

Inconclusive Matches:

Start a Discussion Discussions about Theodore